Skip to Main Content.
Site navigation
Fidelity.com Home
  • Customer Service
  • Profile
  • Open an Account
  • Virtual Assistant Opens in a new window
  • Log In
  • Customer Service
  • Profile
  • Open an Account
  • Virtual Assistant Opens in a new window
  • Log Out
  • Accounts & Trade
    • Portfolio Log In Required
    • Portfolio
    • AccountPositions Log In Required
    • AccountPositions
    • Trade Log In Required
    • Trade
    • Trading Dashboard Log In Required
    • Trading Dashboard Log In Required
    • Active Trader Pro
    • Transfers
    • Cash Management Log In Required
    • Cash Management
    • Bill Pay Log In Required
    • Bill Pay
    • Full View Log In Required
    • Full View
    • Security Settings Log In Required
    • Security Settings
    • Account Features Log In Required
    • Account Features
    • Statements Log In Required
    • Statements
    • Fidelity Alternative Investments Program Log In Required
    • Tax Forms & Information
    • Retirement Distributions Log In Required
    • Fidelity Rewards+registered trademark Log In Required
    • Fidelity Rewards+registered trademark Log In Required
    • New Account Checklist Log In Required
    • Lending Solutions-Line of Credit Log In Required
    • Refer a Friend
  • Planning & Advice
    • What We Offer
    • Build Your Plan
    • My Goals
    • Financial Basics
    • Building Savings
    • Robo Investing Plus Financial Advice
    • Wealth Management
    • Find an advisor
    • Retirement
    • Life Events
    • Saving & Investing for a Child
  • News & Research
    • News
    • Wealth Management Insights
    • Watch List Log In Required
    • Quotes
    • Quotes
    • Alerts Log In Required
    • Mutual Funds
    • Stocks
    • Fixed Income, Bonds & CDs
    • ETFs
    • Options
    • Markets & Sectors
    • IPOs
    • Annuities
    • Learning Center
    • Notebook
    • Notebook
  • Investment Products
    • Mutual Funds
    • Retirement & IRAs
    • Stocks and Trading
    • Direct Indexing
    • Fixed Income, Bonds & CDs
    • ETFs
    • Options
    • Sustainable Investing
    • Cash Management & Credit Cards
    • Managed Accounts
    • 529 College Savings
    • Health Savings Accounts
    • Annuities
    • Life Insurance & Long Term Care
    • Charitable Giving
  • Why Fidelity
    • The Fidelity Advantage
    • Planning & Advice
    • Trading
    • Straightforward Pricing
    • Insights & Tools
    • Security & Protection
    • Marketplace Solutions
    • About Fidelity
    • Careers
  • Customer Service
  • Profile
  • Open an Account
  • Virtual Assistant Opens in a new window
  • Log In
  • Customer Service
  • Profile
  • Open an Account
  • Virtual Assistant Opens in a new window
  • Log Out
Content and data provided by various third parties and Fidelity − Terms of Use
  • Research >
  • Stocks >
  • News & Events >

Stock Details


  • Snapshot
  • Detailed Quote
  • Advanced Chart &
    Technical Analysis Opens in New Window
  • News & Events
  • Compare
  • Analyst Opinions
  • Research Reports
  • Key Statistics
  • Earnings
  • Dividends
  • Ownership & Insiders
  • Financial Statements
  • SEC Filings

RELATED RESOURCES

  • Stock Research Overview
  • Stock Screeners
  • Markets & Sectors
  • Fidelity Learning Center Opens in New Window
Print Format
Change Text Size:
  • Default text sizeA
  • Larger text sizeA
  • Largest text sizeA

U.S. business fears never ending liability from 'take-home' COVID-19 lawsuits

BY Reuters
— 6:10 AM ET 01/12/2022

By Tom Hals

(Reuters) - As COVID-19 cases surge in the United States, businesses say they fear a California court ruling has increased the likelihood that companies will be sued for infections, even by people who are not employees or customers.

The Dec. 21 ruling allowed a wrongful death lawsuit to proceed against See's Candies Inc, owned by Berkshire Hathaway (BRK/A), by the family of Arturo Ek of Los Angeles who died in April 2020 at 72 from COVID-19.

See's employed his wife, Matilde Ek, who said she was infected by the coronavirus while working inches apart from sick coworkers, and then her husband caught it from her at home.

The ruling is the first by an appeals court to allow a novel "take-home" COVID-19 lawsuit, which seek damages from a business over allegations of violating safety protocols and setting off a chain of infections beyond the company's premises.

See's, which did not respond to a request for comment, could appeal to California's supreme court.

The See's ruling is only binding in California, but it may offer guidance to judges in other states, legal experts said.

Business groups warned in court papers filed before the See's decision that such a ruling could prompt lawsuits by an infected employee's family and friends, and anyone infected by that circle of people.

The groups called it a "never-ending chain" of liability.

To counter COVID-19 lawsuits, including take-home cases, business interests have persuaded at least 30 states to adopt laws that make it difficult to bring them, often by requiring plaintiffs to show gross negligence.

California wasn't one of those states.

"The appellate court's ruling could open up California employers to frivolous COVID-related lawsuits that will further dampen the ability of small businesses in particular to recover," said Kyla Christoffersen Powell, the president of Civil Justice Association of California, a business group.

Hours after the decision, a California construction worker and his wife cited the ruling to a U.S. appeals court in San Francisco. The couple is seeking to revive a similar lawsuit against Victory Woodworks Inc.

There have been at least 23 take-home COVID-19 lawsuits across the United States, which are all in the early stages. Defendants include Amazon.com Inc, Walmart Inc, Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd, Conagra Brands Inc (CAG) and Pilgrim's Pride, an affiliate of meat producer JBS SA.

The lawsuits generally allege negligence toward COVID-19 protocols: employees were packed into work vans, symptomatic workers were kept in company dorms or infected people weren't screened before entering a worksite. They seek damages on behalf of employees' children and spouses who wound up on ventilators or even died of the disease.

At least six of the lawsuits have been dismissed including against Southwest Airlines Co and six, including two against McDonald's Corp, appear to have resulted in a private settlement, said Stephen Jones, general counsel of Praedicat Inc, a firm that evaluates risks for insurers.

The cases are not limited to employees. Royal Caribbean's (RCL) Celebrity Cruise line was sued in federal court in Miami for a COVID-19 outbreak on a ship, infecting two passengers who brought the disease home to their children. The two sides are scheduled to begin mediation later this month.

"Until you get a jury verdict, we won't know one way or other if there will be an explosion of cases," said Jones.

The See's ruling helped to resolve an initial question that has hung over take-home COVID-19 cases by finding that employers aren't shielded from lawsuits by workers' compensation. The system provides quick payments without the need to prove fault for workplace injuries and in return it blocks lawsuits.

The California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, said Arturo Ek's death was dependent on his wife as a conduit for the virus. His death was not, as See's had argued, dependent on her disease.

The Ek family must still convince a judge that See's owed a duty to family and acquaintances of employees. Plaintiffs have failed to establish that in cases that were dismissed against Southwest Airlines, an Illinois meat processing company and a Maryland hospital.

To ultimately prevail, plaintiffs must also show that there is a link between the workplace and the case of take-home COVID-19.

"You would have to have a situation where an employee came to and from work and neither the employee nor anyone else in the family/household went anywhere else," said Amberly Morgan, an attorney with Fisher Phillips, which defends employers.

(Reporting by Tom Hals in Wilmington, Delaware; Editing by Noeleen Walder and Grant McCool)

Copyright © Reuters 2008. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by caching, framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters. Reuters and the Reuters sphere logo are registered trademarks and trademarks of the Reuters group of companies around the world.

More BRKB News

BRKB has no more news
Fidelity Investments. Copyright 1998–2022 FMR LLC. 
All rights reserved. 

  • Terms of Use|
  • Privacy|
  • Security|
  • Site Map 
Close